Choose from 3 logos

Hi,

I have 3 logos for my Android game and I need your opinion.

Which one do you think will draw user’s attention more?
#1
logo512x512.jpg

#2
logo_with_frame512.jpg

#3
new_logo512.jpg

I’d vote for #2, but without the blue drops.

#3 is an absolute no-go.

#1 looks good to me

Same here …

Maybe #1 but there is no indication of the water-fire relationship …

Here are some suggestions - I am no graphic designer so just suggestions …

fireball_over_water4.jpg

fireball_over_water2.jpg

fireball_over_water.jpg

Thanks for the opinions!

What about this one:

#4
logo_with_water.jpg

#4 is the best then #1

i liked #1.

I liked the #1 better, simple and not cluttered

#2 without water drops

#2 without water